Two devices, one place
Active vs total calories: why do Apple Watch, Oura and Strava differ?
Updated · 6 min read
- Steps
- Cardio
- Heart
- Sleep
Short answer
Active calories leave out the energy you burn at rest; total calories add it. Compare active with active. Strava shows your device's figure or its own estimate.
Apple Watch's Move ring and Oura's active calorie burn leave out the energy that your body burns at rest, while Oura's total burn adds it. Apple, Oura and Strava each describe a different calculation, and Strava shows either the figure that your device sends or its own estimate.
What each number counts
| Number | Where you see it | Kind |
|---|---|---|
| Move ring | Activity app on Apple Watch | Active |
| Workout total | Activity app on Apple Watch: scroll to the bottom, then tap the workout | Total |
| Active Energy | Health app on iPhone | Active |
| Resting Energy | Health app on iPhone | Resting |
| Active calorie burn | Oura app, Today and Activity screens | Active |
| Total burn | Oura app, Activity screen, under Key metrics | Total |
| Calories | Strava activity | Not stated by Strava |
- Active Energy
is the energy that you burn through physical activity and exercise, without the resting energy of that time.
- Resting Energy
is the energy that your body burns at rest, for basic functions such as breathing and circulating blood.
- Total burn
covers 24 hours from 4 AM. Oura starts it from your BMR (basal metabolic rate): the calories that your body needs to keep its vital functions going.
- A workout total
is the total calories burned that the Activity app shows for a workout. It holds both active and resting energy: Apple's developer page tells apps to split a workout's total energy into those two portions.
- Strava's calories
are the figure that your device or app sent with the activity. When no figure is sent, or you record in the Strava app, Strava calculates its own.
Which numbers to compare
- Active with active
Compare the Move ring on your Apple Watch with Oura's active calorie burn. Workouts that Oura exports to Apple Health, including ones that you add by hand, also add their active calories to the Move ring, so the two numbers can share those calories.
- Total with total
Compare Oura's total burn with the total of another tracker for the same 24 hours. For an Apple total, add the Active Energy and the Resting Energy of one day in Health. To open them, follow steps 1 and 2 below. In step 2, type Resting Energy for the second number. That sum is your own calculation: the Apple pages cited here name no daily total, and they do not say when Health's day starts.
- Strava with the device that recorded the activity
Compare Strava's figure with the same activity on that device. On Apple Watch, use the workout total in the table above.
Choose which device takes priority for Active Energy in Health
What each one sends to Health:
| Source | Sends to Health | When |
|---|---|---|
| Apple Watch | Active Energy | Recorded automatically on the watch |
| Oura | Active Energy | When Oura is connected to Apple Health |
| Strava | Calories, in a data type that Strava does not name | With Send to Health on |
- Open the Health app on your iPhone. Tap Browse.
- Tap the search field. Type Active Energy. Tap Active Energy.
- Scroll down. Below Options, tap Data Sources & Access: the list of apps and devices that share Active Energy with Health, with the source that takes priority at the top.
- Tap Edit.
- Touch and hold the Change Order button next to the device that you want to take priority.
- Drag the device to the top of the list. Tap Done.
The pages cited here do not say that one device is more accurate. One basis to choose is wear: put first the device that you wear during more of your activity, since Oura's figure may be slightly off without the ring (see "Oura missed a workout"). Apple's page says that the top source takes priority, and it does not say what happens to the data of the sources below it.
If the numbers still don't match
- Oura's figure differs from another tracker's
Oura says that it records only active calories when it tracks activity. It says that other trackers and health apps combine active calories and BMR, so their estimates may differ slightly from Oura's. Use the comparison under "Active with active".
- A new app went to the top of the list
Apple lists new apps and devices at the top automatically. Set your order again, as in steps 1 to 6.
- Strava sends its calories to Health
In the Strava app, Send to Health is under Settings then Manage Apps and Devices then Health. Look for Strava in the list of step 3. If it is there, drag the device that you want to take priority above it, as in steps 4 to 6. You can also turn off Send to Health. Strava's page lists route information, activity type, distance and time as sent with the calories, so check whether you need those in Health first.
- Oura missed a workout
Oura recommends that you add an activity that you did without the ring. Tap the + button in the bottom right of the Today tab of the Oura app. Tap Add an activity. Add its start time, duration and intensity. Tap Done.
- A Strava activity has no calories
At this time, Strava calculates calories only for rides, runs, walks and hikes. Other activity types show calories only when the device or app that uploads them sends calories. For a run, Strava needs your weight. To add it, tap Profile then Edit Profile in the Strava app. Scroll down to Weight.
- Apple Watch has an old height or weight
On your iPhone, open the Watch app. Tap My Watch then Health then Health Details. Tap Edit. Tap the item that you want to change. See "Why the numbers differ" for how Apple Watch uses these details.
Why the numbers differ
Strava says that calorie calculations are only estimates, and that there are many ways to calculate them. For a ride, Strava uses your power output. For a run, it uses your speed adjusted for slope, your weight and your moving time.
Oura uses METs (metabolic equivalents), a measure of how hard an activity is: an activity of 4 METs burns four times the calories that you burn at rest. Oura counts an activity in your active calorie burn only from 1.5 METs, so that the calories your body uses at rest stay out of it. Apple Watch uses personal information, such as your height, weight, gender and age, to calculate the calories that you burn.
Questions
Why does Strava show more calories than Apple Health for the same activity?
Strava's page does not say whether its calories are active or total. Active Energy in Health leaves out the energy that you burn at rest, so the two figures may not count the same energy.
Does Oura send total calories to Apple Health?
No. Oura's list of what it exports to Apple Health names Active Energy, which excludes your BMR, and it has no entry for total burn or Resting Energy.
Sources
- 1Track daily activity with Apple Watch, Apple Supportsupport.apple.com (opens in a new tab)
- 2activeEnergyBurned, Apple Developer Documentationdeveloper.apple.com (opens in a new tab)
- 3basalEnergyBurned, Apple Developer Documentationdeveloper.apple.com (opens in a new tab)
- 4View your data in Health on iPhone, Apple Supportsupport.apple.com (opens in a new tab)
- 5Manage Health data on your iPhone, iPad, or Apple Watch, Apple Supportsupport.apple.com (opens in a new tab)
- 6Get the most accurate measurements using your Apple Watch, Apple Supportsupport.apple.com (opens in a new tab)
- 7How Oura Measures Steps & Activity, Oura Helpsupport.ouraring.com (opens in a new tab)
- 8Apple Health Integration, Oura Helpsupport.ouraring.com (opens in a new tab)
- 9How Does Strava Calculate Calories?, Strava Help Centersupport.strava.com (opens in a new tab)
- 10Apple Health and Strava, Strava Help Centersupport.strava.com (opens in a new tab)
- 11Edit or Manually Add an Activity, Oura Helpsupport.ouraring.com (opens in a new tab)
- 12How Do I Change My Personal Settings on Strava?, Strava Help Centersupport.strava.com (opens in a new tab)
- 13Apple Watch integration: what Biomon reads and how to connect, Biomonbiomon.io (opens in a new tab)
- 14Oura integration: what Biomon reads and how to connect, Biomonbiomon.io (opens in a new tab)